Future tense as Opposition parties say no to CAA,NRC

By Vijaya Pushkarna





When Bihar Chief Minister and Janata Dal (United) supremo Nitish Kumar called for a debate on the controversial Citizenship (Amendment)Act 2019, and declared that he would not implement the National Register of Citizens in Bihar, it must have been the BJP' s " et tu, Brute?" moment . His party is an important ally  of the BJP in the NDA  government, and the state goes to polls in September this year.

With Nitish, the number of chief ministers who have said they will not implement the CAA and the NRC goes up to over 13. Kerala assembly has passed a resolution to that effect. Punjab Chief Minister Amarender Singh has said he will not put the state government employees on that job.Even the Assam Chief Minister Sarbananda Sonowal  of the BJP is apparently not favorably inclined to it! So much so the Congress  has invited him to defect with his MLAs , drop the lotus and wave his hand -- a Congress hand , and convert his BJP  government into a Congress government!!

Though the CAA and NRC are Central subjects, whether it is elections or census or National Population Register, the Centre cannot accomplish the task without the cooperation of the state governments.

The protest on the streets is gathering strength, and emboldening political parties to take on the government. The Centre will soon be faced with a tough choice : either  rescind the CAA -- saying anything from sorry to a convenient,  "India is not ready for this today", or face serious trouble.

It will be far too much to expect any government, particularly the one helmed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah, to roll back the discriminatory law under pressure from the public or the Opposition.The two are indeed made of sterner stuff.  Remember,  in spite of the nationwide protests,  the government notified the CAA on Jan 10. And when trade unions were on a Bharat Bandh on Jan 8, protesting against disinvestment and privatization, the Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs announced “in principle” approval to disinvestment in many public sector units.

Shah has been saying they will not rest until citizenship   has been granted along the  lines of their law. Modi has twisted the reasons for the protest, saying no Indian was going to be denied citizenship. Both  have skipped the very basis of the protest-- religion coming into the path of the citizenship process.

There are two things they could do. 

First, they will squeeze the states of anti- CAA chief ministers,  dry them of funds. Shashi Tharoor, the Congress leader and MP representing Thiruvanandapuram in Kerala says the Centre has refused the state funds for flood relief, in spite of the fact that the tiny coastal state was ravaged by floods like no other. More such denial of funds on flimsy grounds --but really on account of the politics of CAA --will expose Modi's " cooperative federalism".  The protests will gather momentum and the Governors could be physically targeted, leading to even more chaos.

Second, the Centre can dismiss the state governments citing  law and order problems, and impose President' s rule, and complete the NRC groundwork. It is another matter that the “hum documents nahin dikhayenge “ (we won’t show our documents) campaign is spreading like wild fire on social media. This could reduce the exercise to a farce.

The way out clearly rests with  the Supreme Court which is slated to take up a clutch of petitions against the CAA  . If the apex court pronounces it unconstitutional, the matter ends there.

That makes the possibility of scenario one—the Centre denying funds to the states  that refuse to implement CAA -- more real. But can President' s rule go on for ever,  till May 2024?

The Constitution allows for Presidential rule for six months, with an extension of a second six month period, unless there is an Emergency ! 

Testing, protesting times seem to be ahead of us.




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Covid 19 : "The protection lies in our own hands"

Image
By Vijaya Pushkarna



When the enemy is as deadly as the novel corona virus, declared pandemic by the World Health Organisation, how and whydoes our protection lie in our own hands?
Prof Amod Gupta, former Director of the Advanced Eye Care Centre ,Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (PGIMER), Chandigarh, has for decades prescribed “wash your hands regularly, don’t touch your face” to thousands of his patients.
In an exclusive interview, Prof Gupta , honoured as "the teacher of teachers"in ophthalmology, explains how this simple act of washing your hands often and not touching your face, can help prevent the spread of this infection, as well as make us a healthier nation.
Q: What is the reason behind your advise to patients to “wash your hands…”.  A: I worked in the PGI for 42 years, and almost every year there used to be an eye flu epidemic. Practically every resident doctor and the faculty members got this conjunctivitis. Except me! What I was doing was…
Read more

Nizamuddin, India should know, is not about Tablighi Jamaat

Image
By Vijaya Pushkarna


Nizamuddin  has always been about a divine evening of qawalli that touches one’s soul at the Dargah ofsufi saint Khwaja Nizamuddin Auliya, and his spiritual disciple,poet Amir Khusrau—who penned the original, timeless “Damadam Mast Qalandar”. In fact the area gets its name from the sufi saint, and is an iconic cultural landmark of Delhi.

A railway trackdivides it into Nizamuddin West, where the pearl-domed Dargah is located with an eclectic bazaar along narrow lanes of shops owned by Muslims. 
Nizamuddin East,a residential area ,is also where Humayun’s Tomb is located.  The who’s who of the capital—not government—have homes inthis lush and beautiful part of Delhi . One of them was Sheila Dikshit, the much loved late Delhichief minister.
The Dargah has always attractedpeople of other religions too –they would offer “chadars” and tie a string on the marble jali wall, make a secret wish and offer a prayer. Those who want to takevisitors out for good non vegetarian food …
Read more

Why are we all so so angry?

Image
By Vijaya Pushkarna




When India celebrated her 70th Independence Day, television channels showed a hauntingly different yet familiar, soothing version of "Jana Gana Mana". The National Anthem was sung by a choir from the North East, and the person behind it was Vandana Kohli.

Well known in the circuit of documentary makers and music, Vandana  never stops surprising anyone who meets her even after two or three weeks. Her conversation is always about something else. For she is on to something new, creative, and  no less challenging or interesting  than what you last saw her do. Not that she has stopped doing that!

Yet there are many who will associate Vandana  with anger. At a time when the  real PDA --Public Display of Anger -- be it on the roads, at home, in schools, why...even in the highest institution of our democracy , is constantly on the rise , Vandana has made it her own subject thanks to her  award winning documentary on anger . Every frame in it gets more and more r…
Read more